Title: Automated Driving (AD) Residual Risk

Author(s): Helen Monkhouse, Michael Orgill

Publication Event: Safety-Critical Systems Symposium 2026

Publication Date: 2025-12-09

Resource URL: https://scsc.uk/r3350.pdf

Abstract:

Automated driving standards, such as ISO 21448 and ISO/TS 5083 re-quire vehicle developers to define risk acceptance criteria for their AD-equipped vehicle products and to base operational deployment decisions on the vehicle’s perceived residual risk. To support deployment decisions, this paper presents a safety case argument pattern and method that derives risk acceptance criteria for, and quantifies the residual risk in, the behavioural competencies required from the AD-equipped vehicle in its proposed operational domain. This includes documenting the rationale that underpins the risk acceptance criteria choice and conveying the confidence that ought to be attached to the vehicle’s operational capability, given the quantified residual risk determined through testing. While the method proposed shows promise for the behavioural competencies considered thus far, further re-search is needed to determine whether the approach scales for complex deployments. Additionally, the extent to which this approach supports stakeholders making operational capability decisions, during an AD-equipped vehicle’s deployment, remains to be seen.